Reviews are a real part of how I pick a hotel, but they’ve never been the whole picture for me, and one trip taught me exactly why.
How I Actually Filter Hotels
My process is pretty consistent. I start on Hotels.com or Booking.com and filter by price first. Then I switch to the map view and check where each option actually sits relative to the airport or train station I’ll be using, since that shapes the whole trip’s logistics more than people give it credit for. Once I’ve narrowed it down to a few hotels near the transportation hub I actually need, that’s when I start looking at photos and reviews.
Over years of traveling, I’ve noticed hotel-supplied photos are often outdated, tightly cropped, or shot from an angle chosen to flatter the property. Written reviews, especially from guests who actually stayed there, tend to reveal what the photos don’t. But not all reviews are equal, and some are more useful than others.
What the Reviews Told Me, and What They Didn’t
I once picked a hotel because the listing said it was a few blocks from the beach, with rooms that had beach views. The photos looked good. The reviews weren’t negative, and read like what you’d expect from an older, well-kept property: “an older property, well maintained,” “located in a historic part of town, kept up nicely.” I checked the location on Google Maps, confirmed it was where it claimed to be, and booked and prepaid for a night.
Ready to narrow it down? How to Compare Two Travel Destinations →
When I worked out how to actually get there, the realistic options were a taxi or the city bus. I’d been riding local buses for days by that point and felt confident finding my way. The bus dropped me a block or so short, and I walked the rest.
The property itself matched the reviews: a genuinely well-maintained older building. But when I opened the room’s window expecting the advertised beach view, I was looking straight into a large, overgrown tree blocking about 90% of it. The hotel hadn’t technically lied — you could see the beach, through the leaves and branches, if you looked for it. And the beach really was only a few blocks away, exactly as listed. What the listing and the reviews left out was that the hotel sat at the top of a steep hill, so those few blocks meant a walk down the hill to the beach and back up again afterward. “Close” was accurate as a straight-line distance and misleading as a practical description.
None of this made it a bad trip. The hotel was clean, safe, the meals were genuinely good, and I slept well. But neither the photos nor the reviews described the tree or the hill, and both were the kind of detail that actually would have changed how I felt about the booking going in.
What Actually Helps You Read a Review
A few things I’ve come to rely on since:
- Extreme ratings tend to carry less nuance. A review that’s all praise or all complaint rarely mentions the specific tradeoffs that actually matter to you. The reviews sitting in the middle, with both a compliment and a complaint in the same sentence, are usually the ones worth reading closely.
- Sort by recency, not just rating. A property can change — new management, a renovation, a construction project next door — and a glowing review from two years ago won’t reflect any of that. Check what people are saying now, not just what earned the most upvotes.
- Check the map yourself, don’t take “close” at face value. A listing that says “a few blocks from the beach” is describing distance, not terrain. Look at the actual elevation and route, especially somewhere hilly, before you assume walkable means easy.
- Notice what’s missing, not just what’s there. My tree-blocked “beach view” wasn’t a lie in any review — it just wasn’t mentioned. If a listing highlights a feature (a view, a short walk, a quiet street) and the reviews are silent on it entirely, that silence is worth noticing.
None of this means distrust every review. It means read for the details, cross-check the ones that matter to your specific trip, and treat “not mentioned” as its own kind of information.
Before and After This Step
If you’re comparing hotels for a booking, it’s worth checking real coverage options too — I use Hotels.com as my own starting filter for price and location before I ever get to reviews. For the step before this one, see our guide to finding a destination that fits you, and if you’re still narrowing down where to go at all, comparing travel costs between destinations covers that decision. Our Free Trip Planner Starter gives you a structure to track what you find as you compare options, rather than trying to hold it all in your head.
Your next step
How to Research a Destination Before Booking →
